The following questions are from Bill Tammeus’ blog. I’ll indent the questions quoted and interject my own thoughts between them.
Faith Matters
I’ve got lots of questions for you about prayer and events like these, but I’ll try to limit myself to a few basic ones:
* What difference does it make if one person prays or a billion people pray if they’re essentially praying for the same thing?
First, a quibble with Bill: “Praying for” sounds specific to prayer with a request, let’s keep this more general than that.
On earth it is good to be on a prayer team with a billion members. It is good to have your heart engaged and aligned with your fellow travelers to the grave. Beyond that I wonder if that is the kind of unity Christ prayed for in John 17:21 when He said “That they all may be one”. Also, the Apostle Paul describes the unity of the members of the body in 1st Corinthians 12:12. I think if you’re praying with a billion brothers in Christ it is more likely a sign that you have entered into the one universal body of Christ on earth than it is if you are praying something that no one else is praying. Bill probably wrote “A billion people” nonspecifically, just a whole lotta folks, but it happens that the membership of the Catholic Church is one billion.
* That is, does God count and respond only when the prayer volume hits critical mass?
No, the Bible has stories of God’s response to the single prayers of individuals and God’s will is not subject to override by a 2/3 majority vote. God is perfect, timeless and unchanging. His “mind” is not to be changed.
* Is prayer meant to change God, change the world or change the people praying?
Prayer is meant to align the will of the person praying with God’s will. In prayer we lift our hearts to God. That’s changing us. God can respond, but we’d continue to pray if He didn’t.
* Are well-written, theogically vetted prayers better than extemporaneous utterances?
That’s like asking if cookies baked by a loving child taste better than the cookies you get at a bakery. What Bill calls theologically vetted prayer is the bakery cookie, it’s technically correct, never burnt and the recipe is a known winner. The extemporaneous [defined] prayer is the child’s cookie, it might be oblong, hard and salty but it was baked with love. Do I have to pick, Bill?
* Do you feel differently about prayer if you know that people in Poland and India and Japan and Colombia are praying with you?
No. I might feel differently about those people overseas, but this isn’t about constructed emotional responses. Here is senior demon Screwtape’s advice to tempter Wormwood on matters of feelings and prayer:
“When they meant to ask Him for charity, let them, instead, start trying to manufacture charitable feelings for themselves and not notice that this is what they are doing. When they meant to pray for courage, let them really be trying to feel brave. When they say they are praying for forgiveness, let them be trying to feel forgiven. Teach them to estimate the value of each prayer by their success in producing the desired feeling; and never let them suspect how much success or failure of that kind depends on whether they are well or ill, fresh or tired, at the moment.”
~ C.S. Lewis THE SCREWTAPE LETTERS
The Ironic Catholic gave these questions thoughtful replies to my earlier post here.