Paper Lion - reviewed
Paul Shirley has been cut from the Suns NBA basketball team and from my reading list. One of those two things is going to cost him $750,000. Paul wrote an online journal (don’t call it a blog, that’ll only make him mad) on NBA.com that was good enough to get him some attention in the press. Now if the athlete - author could just get similar attention on the court.
Also deleted from my reading list is author - athlete George Plimpton’s Paper Lion. Paper Lion is considered the pinnacle of sports literature, albeit the winner in a one-horse race. George Plimpton tried out with the 1963 Detriot Lions in an undercover exercise in participatory journalism for Sports Illustrated. In ‘63 Bob Uecker was a second year catcher with the Braves, still a ballplayer, and not yet the joke known as ‘Mr. Baseball’.
In ‘63 George Plimpton worked out with the Detroit Lions.

The apex of George’s football career was his losing yardage on 5 consecutive snaps in a intrasquad scrimmage. That’s a far cry from getting paid to play in the NBA as Paul Shirley just did, but since the Suns just told Mr. Shirley something like “We think we can find a more cost-effective way to warm that little section of bench you’ve been minding for us.” perhaps the chasm between their respective athletic gifts is one we can fathom after all.
I don’t know if Paul Shirley is familiar with Plimpton’s work… maybe the more recent body of work would be familiar to the young ballplayer from Kansas.

George appeared in an episode of The Simpsons as host of the “Spellympics” and had a recurring role as Carter’s grandfather on ER, then there was that ‘Good Will Hunting’ role.
I never really understood Plimpton before reading this book. From the vantage point of my childhood sofa circa 1980 he was like the Rainbow Afro Guy that held up John 3:16 signs, he was just a guy with an inexplicable knack for getting on TV. He seemed to be offering up some permanent kind of self-deprecating satire without a particular self worthy of all the attention.
Plimpton was a participant, not a parody. The crowd that watched him call plays in that Pontiac, Mi. scrimmage determined that he must have been a clown sent in by Detroit management to lighten the mood and amuse the fans. The truth is a much more difficult thing to bear. He trained and studied for weeks, he did his best to succeed and he looked the fool for it. What’s worse is that he did that to bring a true sense of being a football player to his reader. He was calling plays in that huddle on my behalf, he stood eye to eye with a professional defensive unit bent on his destruction and humiliation because you and I have never had the chance.
Thanks to the magic of the written word and Paper Lion I’ve been able to call out ‘hut three‘ and feel the ball smack against my hand. It makes me wonder what it’s like to be an NBA player, and hope that Paul Shirley or someone like him gets a chance to tell me.








